Treadmill vs. Pavement: The Running Debate at He's Fit

Click here for the Lead Stories

Treadmill vs. Pavement: The Running Debate

Posted December 21, 2007 at 12:45 PM by Megan Hueter

Section: His Fitness, Cardio Training, Injuries & Rehab, His Gear & Apparel, Equipment, His Health, Physical Health

running on pavement With the low temperatures and adverse weather, it’s no wonder that many exercisers choose to hibernate and sweat in the gym instead of going out in the elements. But a great debate among all those fit is one of determining which is better: the treadmill or the pavement. When it comes to the winter season, research points positives and negatives in both directions.

The reason the treadmill feels “easier” on the body is because the ground is actually being pulled underneath your feet (meaning, your feet are not pulling your body forward, as they would if you were running outside), AND there are no other factors such as wind resistance. However, some research indicates that you can supplement this by running at a 1% incline with slight resistance.

One good thing is that treadmills are actually a little less harsh on your knees. This is because many are padded, and have a “give” when you run on them. This makes them a great option if you are injury prone, have knee or ankle pain, or if you are slightly overweight. Running on the pavement can be very harsh on knees and the body. For example, many runners suffer from patellofemoral knee injuries (injuries to the knee cap), damage to the iliotibial band (a muscle on the outside of the thigh) caused by friction with the thighbone, or chondromalacia patella (the softening of the kneecap cartilage often characterized by grinding and popping under the kneecap). Further, many runners complain of shin splints (pain in the shin area of the lower leg caused by friction of the muscles and the tibia “shin” bone). All of these injuries are common among runners who train outside and can be extremely painful, and can possibly be prevented by training on a treadmill.

The other issue is the mental one. We all know that running is a tough, grueling sport. It requires a large amount of mental strength. Many people love running outside to enjoy the view, be in tune with nature and actually feel like they are going somewhere. Many guys hate running on the treadmill because it’s boring and monotonous.

In terms of physical gain, you can also compare your indoor and outdoor running by determining your rate of perceived exertion. This basically means that on a scale of 6 to 20, if your “perceived exertion” is around the same for both workouts, you’re probably getting the same quality workout. Below is the scale you should use to determine this.

Rate of Perceived Exertion Scale:
6 No exertion at all
7 Extremely light
8
9 Very light - (easy walking slowly at a comfortable pace)
10
11 Light
12
13 Somewhat hard (It is quite an effort; you feel tired but can continue)
14
15 Hard (heavy)
16
17 Very hard (very strenuous, and you are very fatigued)
18
19 Extremely hard (You can not continue for long at this pace)
20 Maximal exertion

In comparing indoor and outdoor workouts, if you add your 1% incline and slight resistance on the treadmill, I don’t think you’ll see that much of a difference when it comes to the quality of the run. And it could save you from a lot of unnecessary pain. But if you’re training specifically for an outdoor event, by all means, expose yourself to the elements. Get your body used to running in the cold. This will be the best way to prepare your muscles for the big event.

Research sources and for more information: [About.com 1]; [About.com2]; [Memorial Hermann Sports Medicine Article]; [picture]

27 comments, add yours |

Permalink |

Share this article

Tags: cardio, chondromalacia patella, endurance, fitness, health, iliotibial band, injury prevention, it band, knee pain, men, men's health, pain, patellofemoral knee injuries, pavement, rate of perceived exertion, rpe, running, shin pain, stamina, treadmill

Like what you see? Subscribe to our feed!

27 Responses to “Treadmill vs. Pavement: The Running Debate” (Leave a reply)

Men's Health Magazine said:

Great article, I personally enjoy outside activities much more
May 21, 2008 at 02:44 PM
Motorised Treadmill from England said:

Very interesting article - its an fascinating debate, but as your article concludes in the openeing paragraph..I too believe there are positives and negatives to both.

From my personal experience as a personal trainer, treadmill use seems to favour the ‘older generation’ a bit more who do not want to damage their joints and just want to have a nice smooth run.

It is very common to see younger people running out on country roads nowdays - I guess it presents more of a challenge, and is a bit more ‘adventurous’.

I think a balance between the two is ideal.
September 14, 2008 at 12:12 PM
Motorcycle Fairings said:

I like to run in the tracks cos they have better resistance to the impact of your weight on the ground.
November 18, 2008 at 05:00 PM
Solstice Online money said:

Thanks, it is very good, I like it very much Solstice Online money
February 9, 2009 at 10:48 PM
JJ said:

Thanks you so much for this interesting article. I actually prefer the outdoors as I feel that I’m one with the nature (as you mentioned in the article). On the other hand my knees do feel painful so I might be making a big mistake for the long run.

Guess best thing to do is play outdoor < a href="http://www.playing65.com">backgammon</a> :-)
February 28, 2009 at 03:26 AM
requiem gold said:

I like a game which needs to use requiem gold
March 5, 2009 at 08:41 PM
cheap mesos said:

You can change a lot cheap mesos for play games.
March 26, 2009 at 12:21 AM
online shopping from India said:

Really very nice and good information you share here. I read your entire post and really very good info on
fitness treadmill. Really very nice and fantastic information you share here. Thanks for your information.
April 10, 2009 at 04:57 AM
Malory from Britain said:

Give please. To believe in God or in a guiding force because someone tells you to is the height of stupidity. We are given senses to receive our information within. With our own eyes we see, and with our own skin we feel. With our intelligence, it is intended that we understand. But each person must puzzle it out for himself or herself. Help me! It has to find sites on the: outpatient drug rehab. I found only this - drug addiction center. Relevant how to choose the best alcohol treatment center for your drinking problems tell someone else about alcohol treatment centers. Find addiction websites plus addiction, lcohol treatment agency z community rehab addiction, drug and alcohol rehabilitation, treatments. With love :eek:, Malory from Britain.
May 19, 2009 at 09:21 AM
Gloria from Mozambique said:

Hello everyone. Pleasure to sign your guest book. I work for an advertising agency in Mozambique. Help me! I can not find sites on the: Topamax and bulimia. I found only this - topamax drug. Terbinafine information, learn about terbinafine, terbinafine forums, how to take terbinafine, terbinafine side effects, terbinafine interactions. Excision of these drugs for a doctor lamisil is using it. Best regards ;-), Gloria from Mozambique.
June 23, 2009 at 07:26 PM
Alexander from Africa said:

Hi all. Computer Science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes. Help me! I can not find sites on the: Sizing air conditioners. I found only this - mini portable air Conditioners. Gas heat pump multi air conditioners adopting ra. Welcome to the premier industrial air conditioners ductless resource. Thanks :confused:. Alexander from Africa.
July 4, 2009 at 07:50 PM
Tol7tuy from Ki said:

Einfach das Grauen wie ist es interessant wie diese Informationen aussehen würden wenn aller im Gegenteil wäre?? Niemand streitet sollend info, aber aus irgendeinem Grunde denke ich dass die eigenen Bemerkungen wir überhaupt nicht aufsparend werden wir unterstützen.
August 12, 2009 at 02:08 PM
Juli from Lv said:

Ahora esto se ve muy entretenido, extremadamente mundial. Se puede por sí mismo sin duda andar en altercados con este motivo pero que no hables mí se alegro..
August 25, 2009 at 04:12 AM
Лечение наркомании from Lv said:

I have heard that to keep feet helps not the exercises but the air that we brieth when we do exercises
September 21, 2009 at 05:34 AM
Treadmills from UK said:

For runners worried about shock or impact injuries, a treadmill with a good shock absorbent running belt can reduce injuries by a good 40%. Features in the consoles on modern treadmills (such as race and competition modes) add to the motivation factor.
September 27, 2009 at 08:33 AM
лечение алкоголизма from Uk said:

To run better on the big space. It distracts mind from problems and calms.
September 28, 2009 at 12:08 PM
BASILIA - allergic bronchitis from US said:

Penso che si sbagliano. Sono in grado di provarlo. Scrivere a me in PM, parlare.
September 29, 2009 at 08:35 AM
BETTE - bronchitis, contagious from US said:

Credo che lei abbia sbagliato. Sono sicuro. Cerchiamo di discutere di questo. Scrivere a me in PM.
September 29, 2009 at 09:26 AM
BENITA - treating bronchitis from US said:

E ‘vero! Penso che questo sia una buona idea. Pienamente d’accordo con lei.
September 29, 2009 at 10:33 AM
BOBETTE - difference between viral and bacterial b from US said:

Mi dispiace, niente non posso aiutarvi. Penso che troverai la giusta soluzione. Non disperate.
September 29, 2009 at 11:20 AM
testking VCP-410 from Spain said:

Ground shaking content i get form your blog. Very nice post about running debate. Thanks for your beneficial information about testking 70-432 and testking 70-452 certifications. These are the best certifications in the world.
December 12, 2009 at 07:33 AM
testking 70-621 from Spain said:

Ground shaking content i get form your blog. Very nice post about running debate. Thanks for your beneficial information about testking 642-586 and testking 70-298 certifications. These are the best certifications in the world.
December 14, 2009 at 11:57 PM
CP Lights from U.K said:

That was a very nice article I really like it.
December 28, 2009 at 09:37 AM
Fraser Hydraulics from U.K said:

They do generate energy and I have saw these kinds of machines get used by most of the fitness centers.
December 28, 2009 at 09:41 AM
Yuriy from UA said:

Today it looks painfully exciting prohibitively universal. Heavens clear case bicker about this, but did not say I’m thrilled.
January 8, 2010 at 01:27 PM
Видеонаблюдение from Ukraine said:

Running is useful and very helpful. It helps keep body in fit
January 12, 2010 at 02:41 PM
Treadmill from UK said:

I must admit, this is a great article which touches on some very important points, and gives a very fair assessment..

I would agree with the conclusion. I would add that it is not a bad idea for an average user to run outside as well (during summer months for example) as motivation can easily be lost if you are always on the treadmill. It is always nice to get some good fresh air, and of course test your fitness levels outside :-D of course you should always invest in a nice pair of trainers to minimise damage to joints.

Personally, I think a good combination of both is the answer for a lot of people…
January 14, 2010 at 11:02 AM